Joe Biden in an interview with the New York Observer on Senator Barack Obama's likely candidacy for President:
"I mean, you got the first mainstream African-American who is articulate and bright and clean and a nice-looking guy," he said. "I mean, that’s a storybook, man."Translation of Biden into American English: "Most n%%%%rs can't talk, are stupid, don't wash and are ugly. This one - who suprisingly can talk, is not stupid, does wash and looks good - is a very rare miracle. But he surely cannot be President, are you kidding me?"
But—and the "but" was clearly inevitable—he doubts whether American voters are going to elect "a one-term, a guy who has served for four years in the Senate," and added: "I don’t recall hearing a word from Barack about a plan or a tactic."
Reality: Black dialect is as "articulate" as any other dialect or language. Just as Jewish public officials have occasionally used Yiddish terms or other stylized speech on some occasions, and as Southern white politicians indulge in regional dialect largely unintelligible in Seattle, black and non-black candidates and non-candidates use a variety of speaking styles to achieve their goals. For black candidates, sometimes this involves the use of black dialect grammar, lexicon, style and intonation, to which speech patterns many white listeners are less familiar or less well-disposed. Speaking purely personally, I don't care for Southern white dialect(s) myself as an aesthetic or style matter, but my prejudices don't make their rhetorical use by Bill Clinton or Fred Thompson "inarticulate."
Reality: The pool of prior African-American candidates for President includes Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, Shirley Chisholm and Alan Keyes. I will accept that Alan Keyes and Shirley Chisholm are not "mainstream" but arguably Keyes is as mainstream as Sharpton and Jackson. Keyes, Sharpton and Jackson are all extremely well known for their fiery oratorical gifts. Their policy prescriptions are controversial, but so are Sam Brownback's. Jackson and Sharpton are controversial figures for reasons unrelated to their campaigns, but no one would ever confuse them with Mushmouth.
Reality: The term "articulate" is infamous in the black community as a commonplace condescension by whites seeking to imply that a black speaker merely exceeds the (by implication) low speaking skills and standards of most black Americans.
Opinion: Obama is a less compelling speaker than Sharpton, Jackson or Keyes. While Obama is very good, he reminds me of the "honorable man" Brutus when the crowd is waiting for Marc Anthony.
Opinion: I don't know whether Biden is personally a racist who believes that most black Americans including black presidential candidates are ugly idiots who cannot speak well and won't bathe. My suspicion is that Biden is not such a racist, but is simply willing amorally to deal the "race card" early from the bottom of the deck, to quote attorney Robert Shapiro after the Orenthal Simpson trial. Biden has wanted to be president since his umbilical cord was cut, and he won't tolerate the threat of a charismatic young senator stepping ahead of him and his dream without a nasty fight. Biden has been willing to reach out to Southern revanchist throwbacks in South Carolina by reminding them warmly that his state Delaware was a slave state and therefore culturally southern. This is of course garbage; Wilmington is a suburb of Philadelphia and is connected by frequent subsidized commuter rail to that city. Wilmington's Little Italy lies 60 miles northeast up the Northeast Corridor from Baltimore's Little Italy, and lies barely north (and 2800 miles east) of San Francisco's Little Italy. Sad indeed that this Democrat's lust for power is so overwhelming that he will indulge racist revanchism, racist stereotypes of his opponent's ethnic community and his state's infamous complicity in slavery in order to win.
Opinion: Biden should be ashamed for providing attack language for the Republican nominee to use in September 08.
Opinion: Biden's campaign blog comments are saccharine to the point of hyperglycemic coma. Why have comments or even a blog at all if only the syrupy sweet comments get in; you are better off not using the blog structure at all, lest real bloggers mock your blog as a sockpuppet with the fingers sticking up through holes in the sockpupper's sock. Better off just having your deputy media guy write some copy and get rid of the whole blog charade. At this point, DKos and RedState would probably agree to a joint production to humiliate Biden's "blog" [sic].
Reality: A broadcast of the interview tape from the New York Observer article is available at the site above. Some have suggested that listening to the tape mitigates some, but not necessarily all, of the valid criticisms.
Opinion: Since I have not listened to the tape, I have no opinion about it yet. It's hard for me to see how any combination of pauses or verbal commas could salvage this piece of offensive. rhetoric stupidity from this aspirant Head of State and Commander-in-Chief of the Army and Navy. But we shall see, er, hear.
UPDATE: Joe Biden:
"I deeply regret any offense my remark in the New York Observer might have caused anyone. That was not my intent and I expressed that to Senator Obama."Barack Obama:
"I didn't take Senator Biden's comments personally, but obviously they are historically inaccurate. After all, we've had presidential candidates like Jesse Jackson, Shirley Chisholm, Carol Mosely Braun and Al Sharpton. They gave a voice to many important issues through their campaigns and no one would call them inarticulate."Crablaw failed to recall Senator Carol Mosely Braun's campaign for President and regrets the oversight.
Labels: Biden, Election 2008, Obama, race
Trackback
Permalink/Below the Fold





